Your Options:
| Features | DVR From Cable Co | TiVo DVR | Build Your Own PC-DVR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Record SD | Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Record HD | Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Take Programs Mobile | NO |
Kind-Of *2 |
Yes |
| Watch on Main TV | Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Watch Anywhere at Home | NO |
Kind-Of *3 |
Yes |
| Watch Your Movies | NO |
Kind-Of *4 |
Yes |
| Listen to Music | NO |
Kind-Of *4 |
Yes |
| Internet Programs | NO |
NO |
Yes |
| Rent Movies Online | Kind-Of *1 |
Yes *5 |
Yes |
| Download Movies | NO |
NO |
Yes |
| Home Automation | NO |
NO |
Yes |
| Home Security | NO |
NO |
Yes |
| Cost PER MONTH | $12-$18/Month/TV |
$12/mo 1st TV, $6 each additional |
$0 - Really - $0 |
Notes: |
|
|---|---|
| *1: Only rent movies from Cable company; Very limited selection | *4: Movies and Music can be accessed by a TiVo through TiVo desktop but codecs are limited and access is difficult |
| *2: Take mobile through TiVo desktop - very slow transfer, limited playback rights | *5: Renting and buying movies works well through TiVo although you have to buy from one of their partners. That movie takes up valuable hard drive space forever. No ability to access media via P2P |
| *3: TiVo DVRs can share a recording list but you are required to have a series 2 or better TiVo at every TV in your home (up front cost) and pay monthly for the extra DVRs to enjoy that feature. |
I Don't know about you but I see a pattern here!!
Building your Own PC Based DVR is low cost, has no monthly subscription, many more features than anything on the market, and you will feel so much better about yourself...
WHOLE-HOME and Portability:
I’d like to specifically draw attention to the whole-home part, as once people understand that piece, it is usually the motivating factor for taking on this kind of project.
If you build your own PC DVR, not only can you record ANYTHING, you also now own all those files. That may sound simple, but it is huge as our media collections begin to grow. With other systems, the recordings are encrypted, and while you have temporary access, you can’t just grab a program off your TiVo or off your cable company DVR and do with it whatever you like – there are keys, encryptions, special ways to access it and other big brother stuff.
Build your own PC DVR and you get more freedom:
Want to watch a program in your bedroom instead of the main TV? You bet
Want to take a program to a friends house and watch it? You bet
Want to start watching a program in the living room, get tired and finish in bed? Yep
Want to record that movie off HBO and keep it in your collection forever? Oh Yeah
Want to cut down your Cable AND TiVo bills? Easy


